Scientist and apologist Jonathan Sarfati of Creation Ministries International doesn’t mess around. When he tackles the evolutionist view, he goes right to the top.
That’s why his most recent book, The Greatest Hoax on Earth?, took on evolution’s and atheism’s most popular promoter, British scientist Richard Dawkins, whose most recent book is The Greatest Show on Earth.
The subtitle of Dawkins’ book is The Evidence for Evolution. That of Jonathan’s book is Refuting Dawkins on Evolution.
’Nuff said?
“Dawkins is widely regarded as a champion of evolution and Darwinism and atheism,” Jonathan says. “He’s a vocal atheist, anti-Christian, and evolutionist. It’s very interesting he wrote his book on the bicentennial of Darwin’s birth because he admits that his previous books really did not prove evolution, but assumed it to be true. In The Greatest Show, he was trying to remedy that by producing the best possible arguments he could for evolution.”
But, in Greatest Hoax?, Jonathan shows that “here’s the best they can do, and here’s how it can’t add up.”
Jonathan ably plows through Dawkins’ arguments point by point, highlighting not only the weaknesses in Dawkins’ science, but his failures in logic as well.
For example, when Dawkins complains in Greatest Show that the human body is inefficient and wouldn’t have been created by an intelligent designer as it is, but more likely is the product of haphazard evolution, Jonathan deftly exposes the fallacies of his argument.
“An assertion about what a designer would or would not do is actually a pseudo-theological argument, not a scientific argument that mutations and natural selection could produce a particular complex design.” (Emphasis in original, page 266.)
Creationism works better as science because it doesn’t have the “prior assumption of materialism, which is being a hindrance to science in so many ways,” Jonathan says. (Materialism maintains that material things are all that exist and that nothing supernatural can exist.)
Instead, the creationist view “encourages research in the beginning because we’re given dominion over creation (Genesis 1:28) and the great early scientists believed that they were following God’s dominion then by doing scientific research,” Jonathan says.
“Atheism and evolution can’t justify the scientific endeavor.”